Home | Matthew Blaylock | Everett Mugg | Kevin Carver | Jack Lewis | Joe Jacobs | Jay Staton | Jay Maddox | Lisa Fowler | Debbi Willis | James Langley | News

NASCAR’s Dirty Little Secret: Rules Breakers or Rules Makers?

 

February 22, 2007

Jay Staton - SCR

 

Speedweeks or Sleezeweeks? The finish of the Daytona 500 came as an appropriate exclamation point to a week that by now every race fan on the face of the planet—including Formula One fanatics—is aware of. 

 

Internet Search engines posted the title: “How to cheat in NASCAR” on their homepage. Parental-control-types screamed for stronger punishment for the “cheaters”, and media keyboards everywhere have been smoking on a nightly basis. 

 

Most of the pre-race hoopla centered on Michael Waltrip and the “substance” in his intake manifold, and, for that matter, gas tank. 

 

Admittedly, it was not the most brilliant attempt at cheating ever tried by the as yet unnamed guilty party, but it was the largest of the fines and the most embarrassing of the infractions during Speedweeks.

  

So be it, but then… Jeff Gordon’s car came in AFTER the 150 mile qualifying race a full inch low and NASCAR merely put him in the back of the field, citing lack of intent. 

 

Now there is a clear statement to the competitors, NOT! Try something and lose one hundred points, or get a shrug of the shoulders and a wink and a nod. 

 

Ray Evernham also has a solid point: The “illegal” (that is, this week, not last week, and who knows about next week) bolts holding on the spoiler of his Dodge were found BEFORE the race, before qualifying even. The larger teams employ dozens of engineers, and these guys are not guessing at stagger on Sundays. They are trying to find advantages not named in the rule book, and really, those advantages often eventually find their way into passenger cars. 

 

Inspectors are there to determine what is and what is not inside the letter or the intent of the rules, but to assess a fine before the car has qualified—as in the case of Evernham and Waltrip… is it an inspection or a Fine Assessment Process? 

 

Further compounding this problem is the legendary “Call” from NASCAR officials. Although never admitted to by a competitor (one would have to be crazy or suicidal or both to do so), it has long been rumored that certain Teams are given “the call” and run a WHOLE lot better on race day. 

 

Somehow the Dale Earnhardt Incorporated (DEI) cars were just unbelievably dominant a few years back. Dale Earnhardt Jr. says he wishes his motors ran NOW like they did THEN. It does make one wonder just where all that horsepower came from.  

 

In a previous year Junior also has clearly passed under the yellow line at Daytona and it was ignored, and perhaps in the biggest silliness intentionally spun himself out to cause a caution that would benefit him and admitted to it on national television. NASCAR’s initial response, just because he SAID it did not mean he MEANT to do it.

    

Advertise on StockCar Review, with advertising rates starting as low as $16.50 per month, you cannot find a better deal. Email us at scr@stockcarreview.com for more information.
 

 

There have been rumors for years about Richard Petty’s last win which just happened to occur when President Reagan was watching the event. 

 

And then there is the flip side of this coin. Sterling Marlin has maintained all along that NASCAR essentially stole a win from his father, “Coo Coo”, as he was black flagged for a non-existent problem and another bigger-name driver went on to win. 

 

Similarly Bill Elliot was black flagged for a loose headlight bucket that was undetectable and held for two laps when his Ford was dominating the field.  

 

This past week, when Waltrip was a broken man and ready to go home, Mike Helton had a talk with him and told him to buck up and race. In a car that he had not practiced in and with a heavy heart, Waltrip then proceeded to cut through the field into the lead IN 13 LAPS! The same car was junk in the 500. Who hands out the restrictor plates again? 

 

Finally, the finish to the 500... With more wrecked cars than could be easily counted, the green stayed out. Was this an exciting finish, definitely? Could Clint Boyer have been injured or worse, absolutely? If you were a driver, would YOU lift the next time the caution comes out? 

 

Meanwhile, there is a clamor for the “CHEATING TO STOP” but the real problem is not the “cheaters,” but the sanctioning body that sets up the game week after week for the circus to go on. In the process it looks surprisingly like a bunch of good old boys trying to influence the outcome of events and look legitimate and fair in the process. I disagree with pretty much everything that CART cheerleader Robin Miller says, but he has this one absolutely nailed. 

 

You see, everyone has an inherent sense of “right” and “wrong” built into us, and it is so tempting to judge others objectively and meanwhile explain off our own transgressions. But there are Objective Rules, only ten of them, and they never change. Lying, either overtly or covertly, is among them. This would include NASCAR officials equally with the competitors. 

 

So what is an obviously befuddled sanctioning body to do? 

 

That’s right, Sports fans; they should do their own best imitation of the Original 10 Rules of All Time. 

 

How, you may ask? It really is quite simple. They have their own Car-of-Tomorrow. Legislate every bolt in the car and put it on their website for the entire world to see. Then, if someone comes up with something outside the rules and it is found before a race, make them change it. If it is found after the race, congratulate them on their win and then add that to the set of rules.

   

SCR is looking for writers in all the series we cover, if interested email us at scr@stockcarreview.com to receive further information.
 

 

Intentional rules breaking should have set fines. If gasoline and tires and motor are important, write the fine amount and suspension length for all to see. This way, a crew chief or a well meaning (but not so bright) crew member with a can of the wrong stuff will think twice about sneaking it into the gasoline tank. 

 

Similarly, on track rules should be written and be absolutely as consistent as can be made humanly possible. Ted Musgrave had a championship taken away (or stolen, depending on one’s perspective) due to passing on the low side, but it worked for the second place finisher in Friday night’s truck race.  

 

There are people in the tower that can flip on that caution light, and as much as I love to see a good finish, people HAVE been killed in this sport-- and on the last lap of the Daytona 500, as Dale Earnhardt Sr. fans can attest. 

 

Fortunately, in our everyday lives we do have that Objective Set of Rules to follow, and they are easily understood as are the penalties for breaking them. Fortunately we also have Forgiveness, and it thankfully hinges on our own forgiveness of others. Mr. France and Mr. Helton, feel free to follow Mr. Waltrip’s lead. Michael Waltrip has asked for another chance. In my book, and in The Book that counts, that is how it is done, and that is more than enough.

  

Questions, Comments;

Email Jay 

 

The views and opinions in this article are that of the writer(s) and not necessarily that of SCR

  

 

Print

Enter content here

Enter content here

Enter content here

Born on: July 8, 2005

Copyright Symbol 2006 StockCar Review.